SlashIndia

The real stories of India.
  
 

Reservation fire engulfs India.

 
By Anonymous at Sat, 2006-05-13 19:45 | General | Reservation

The protests against reservations initiated by medical students in Delhi is now spreading throughout the country.

A group of 200 medical students was lathicharged in Mumbai on Saturday when they blocked a road to the Raj Bhavan to protest against the government’s reservation proposal.

Services at three government medical colleges in Cuttack, Burla and Berhampur cities of Orissa were affected when about 1,200 house surgeons and junior doctors in government medical colleges went on strike...

In Ahmedabad, medical students of different colleges went on an indefinite strike as a mark of solidarity for their counterparts in Delhi.

The Indian Medical Association has called for a "total medical bandh" in Delhi on Monday. It is likely to call a nationwide strike on May 25 if the IMA national committee ratifies the proposal at its meeting in Delhi on May 20-21.

IBNLive has more.

where are the rest

By nxl (not verified) on Sat, 2006-05-13 19:57

delhi medical students are doing a great service to the nation by vehemently opposing governments reservations scheme ....but where are the rest of the student population...especially the much famed iit-ians ....are they too busy studying that they are not able to react to what is happenning around them .. .and what about the other colleges like DU in delhi ???

»

reservation?

By Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 2006-05-14 14:23

Conspicuous Silence

15 years later when Arjun Singh informs the journalists about the reservation policy, there is not much war by the upper castes though there is resentment by the 'meritorious' industrial houses who run on a monarchical basis. Again, the same talks of merit being affected and non-availability of the students from the backward and Dalit communities. It is amusing how people change their stand. Industrialists like Rahul Bazaz, known for the shameless Hindutva lineage, remarked that reservation in the private sector would damage the credibility of big companies in India. The Bazazs should tell the world why most of the business works in India is done by the Bania community. North East South West, it is the Marwadis and Banias who have captured the major institutions with Brahmin their Gurus. The opponents of reservation should also inform why the scavenging work is fixed for the Valmiki community in India. Why is this 'Intellectual property Right' over certain work while ignoring others. Social scientists should also explain why no other community person is seen as doing scavenging work or carrying night soil over head. This meritorious upper caste would then hang their head in shame.
What is happening is most astonishing and show double standard. In 1990, the Dalits were in the forefront of supporting the Mandal Commission Recommendations meant for the backward communities. Today, a number of 'Dalit' intellectuals, who would like to parade Dalit capitalists in Delhi, are asking for a creamy lawyer theory to implement the Mandal Commission Report. An example is being given here of the lone dissenter why should the dissenter argument be taken into account. Mandal gave a report and government accepted it in toto. A person like S.S. Gill who was member secretary of the Mandal Commission today condemns VP Singh for implementing it with political motivation. It is amusing when commentators write of political motivation. Why should not any work done with political motivation? Did not the backward communities voted for the government? It is also important to analyse as why some of the Dalit intellectuals are crying for fixing quota for the Most Backward Communities (MBCs).
Arun Shourie, who spearheaded anti Mandal agitation through his reckless writings and was later rewarded by the Sangh Parivar for persistently abusing the minorities through his newspaper columns, would never had imagined that Mandal would eat his own party. He might never have foreseen the growing assertion among all communities after it. Why was India burning in 1990 and quiet in 2006.
To be sure, in 1990, the people realized that the government that time was determined to give the Dalits and backward their due share in power. One need not to remind that Ministers like Ram Vilas Paswan and Sharad Yadav had become very powerful proponents of the Mandal Mantra. The government did not stay there only. It was bringing a bill in parliament for labour reform particularly related to labours participation in Management, bill on electoral reform under Dinesh Goswami, autonomy to Prasar Bharati apart from putting Dr Ambedkar's statue in Parliament and honoring him with Bharat Ratna. Every of these acts had loud messages. It is this time that the Buddhists converts got right in job reservations. Mandal in 1990 changed the politics of the country. It gave an unprecedented and lethal weapon for the Dalit backward and Adivasis to come together. Every party had to understand the power of Mandal. Over the years, despite talks of globalisation and Hindutva, Mandalisation process continued. In the process, the upper caste leadership of the Hindutva gangs have to play second fiddle. Right from Uma Bharati to Kalyan Singh and Narendra Modi, caste his forced the Sindhi Lal Krishna Advani to ponder over his own future and he is again on another Yatra, knowing fully well, that he has lost his caste battle. The upper castes are silent and protesting just in front of the cameras. A few papers that do not sale much are again trying to instigate people to protest but those who get everything at home cannot protest. Secondly, they know they have their own government and their opposition. A government which just pretend to work for the Dalits and backward and has no real intention to do so. Most of the people know that in Manmohan Singh's safe hand their interest are safe and would be looked after. After-all, Arjun Singh's own track record for social justice is laughable and his politicization of Ministry of HRD is well known. The tricks of anti Hindutva do not work all the time in the same way as the anti Muslim card of Advani failed miserably.
Why Opposition to reservation for backward communities
One needs to understand the psychology of opposition to Mandal. Reservation for Dalits was never implemented properly before 1990. Every time it was informed that due to lack of non availability of the candidates, seats remained vacant and quota was filled by the upper caste particularly those close to the people in power or with big bags. The 1990s changed that the backlog has to be filled with the candidates from the same community. Therefore 1990 is a watershed in the history of India and implementing the Mandal Commission Report VP Singh might have become the most hated politician of the country despite his impeccable credentials, yet, the politics of India has changed.
15 years later when Narsimha Rao crookedly with the help of the Hindutva brigade tried to undo what the Mandal had done. He went overboard to implement the privatization process and added fire to the Hindutva. Therefore, both the demolition of Babari Masjid and growing privatization were part of the Narsimha Rao era which some of our pen pushers termed as glorious. One need not to inform the readers here how Narsimha Rao died. Not a single tear was shed for him.
When the jobs are nowhere and everything is gone private, then why are the upper castes angry at reservation for backward communities? The fact is that seats for Dalits were rarely fulfilled and we had seen huge backlog. There has been no protest. It was easier to curtail the protest of the Dalits because of their numbers and social background. Now, the reservation for backward communities being a reality, the powerful backward communities will hit and break the bone of the upper castes. That is the fear of these. They know that there are enough students from these communities who will join the great institutions of technology and managements.
Today, these pen pushers pretend that reservation should only for the Dalits. Similarly, Dalit opportunists also dance to the tone of their brahmanical masters when they condemn reservation for the backward communities. It is a fact that many of the backward communities should not have been there in the list. But that is not a way to justify that there should not be reservatioN
YES RESERVATION MUST BE THERE BUT FOR A SPECIFIC PERIOD OF TIME ONLY ,LIKE 10 TO 15 YRS

»

Come Touch the Freedom

By Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 2006-05-22 19:42

I am not for Equality ! I am not for Division(quota} ! I am for FREEDOM... FREEDOM....FREEDOM..!!! Guys ! this should be a Quest for Freedom and not a Fight for Equality or Reservation.No two persons are Equal....they cannot be Equal.But they are Unique in their own ways. One is FREE to live.. to love ..and to die. With Freedom comes great Responsibility.What one chooses in Freedom ,becomes one's Responsibility. So guys ! you are the people of this FREE WORLD. Leave your castes, your religions ..... COME TOUCH THE FREEDOM

»

Come Touch the Freedom

By J Samyo (not verified) on Mon, 2006-05-22 19:43

I am not for Equality ! I am not for Division(quota} ! I am for FREEDOM... FREEDOM....FREEDOM..!!! Guys ! this should be a Quest for Freedom and not a Fight for Equality or Reservation.No two persons are Equal....they cannot be Equal.But they are Unique in their own ways. One is FREE to live.. to love ..and to die. With Freedom comes great Responsibility.What one chooses in Freedom ,becomes one's Responsibility. So guys ! you are the people of this FREE WORLD. Leave your castes, your religions ..... COME TOUCH THE FREEDOM

»

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
  
Home | About us | F.A.Q's | Feedback | Contact Us | RSS | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service